Blue Plate 30oz Jar

Blue Plate Mayonnaise, 30 oz

(22 customer reviews)


Or buy 12 for $6.51 per item.

Bring out the flavor in all your favorite foods, from salads and sandwiches to dips, dressings, and sauces.  Our tasty mayonnaise is the perfect addition to any meal.

Out of stock

22 reviews for Blue Plate Mayonnaise, 30 oz

  1. Michelle

    What is going on with Blue Plate Mayonaise? I’ve eaten nothing but Blue Plate all my like and I am 54 years old. The consistency is loose and not firm like it used to be. It also has a rancid aftertaste even though it’s within the expiration date. You changed the label and the product. Bring back New Orleans’ original Mayonaise!!! If I wanted this nasty taste in Mayonaise I’d just buy Hellmans! BRING THE ORIBINAL FORMULA BACK OR YOU WILL LOOSE MANY LONG TOME CUSTOMERS!!!

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Michelle, Thank you for your long time loyalty to Blue Plate Mayonnaise.

      We are sorry to learn of your disappointment in your recent purchase of Blue Plate in that the mayonnaise has a thinner consistency and a rancid taste. As you know, this is not representative of our mayonnaise, and we appreciate you informing us.

      Our Consumer Affairs Department received an undeliverable email notification when attempting to reach out to you. Please call 1-800-535-1961 and they will be happy to assist you.

  2. Tiffany

    Blue Plate has changed. The consistency is different. If it doesn’t get back to the way it’s always been, we will have to find a new mayonnaise. We have always been a Blue Plate only family.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Tiffany, We are sorry to hear you were disappointed with your recent Blue Plate Mayonnaise purchase. Your information was forwarded to our Consumer Affairs Department. Someone will be reaching out to assist you. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer!

  3. Davion Johnson

    Blue plate is the only Mayonnaise that I liked? Been using it my entire life and it does not taste the same to me at all. I actually went on the internet to see if anyone had experienced the same thing that I have because I’m telling you I know my mayo and it’s not the same. Did something get added or subtracted? Let’s talk about it seriously.

    • Reily Foods Company

      HI Davion, We’re sorry to hear that you had this experience. We’ve forwarded your information on to our Consumer Affairs Department. Someone will be reaching out to help. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate user!

  4. Mary parmer

    I too have notice a difference in the taste of Blue Plate mayo which is unpleasant. This is why I went on the internet to see if changes were made to the recipe. I have used this mayo for many years so I know the difference and change to the taste.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Mary, We’re sorry to hear that you were disappointed with the flavor of your Blue Plate Mayonnaise. This information has been forwarded to our Operations and Consumer Affairs Departments. Someone will be reaching out for additional information. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  5. Juliette Wilbourn

    I’m 75 years old and have eaten Blue Plate mayo all my life. The last few jars taste nothing like it used to. The consistency has changed and it has a rancid aftertaste even though a good expiration date. What’s wrong?

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Juliette, We are so sorry that you had experience. Your information was forwarded to our Consumer Affairs Department. Someone will be reaching out to help. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate Mayo consumer!

  6. Annette Bailey

    I have been a fan of Blue Plate and even remember being excited the first time I saw it on the grocery list at Walmart. I was so happy to see the creamy tasty mayo I had loved in the restaurant industry available at the grocery in Missouri! That was over two years ago now and it has changed for in a very bad way! It is not the same creamy tasty mayo. It is like Hellman’s in texture with a taste I can’t even cover up to make it work. Please don’t deny the change I am not alone in noticing the difference. Please return to the original recipe. If it’s money I know I would pay more to get the quality it was in the past!

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Annette, We are sorry to hear you are disappointed with Blue Plate Mayonnaise. Your information was forwarded to our Consumer Relations department. Someone will be reaching out to get more information. Thanks for being loyal Blue Plate Consumer.

  7. Steve jones

    Ive been a Blue Plate Mayo lover for 30 years but it tastes no where as good as it did in GLASS jars. I believe the plastic jars are leaching into the mayonnaise causing the taste to get worse. You dont find pickles or relish in plastic and i dont believe mayonnaise should be in it either. Vinegar, is also a cleaner mixed witj soybean oil ??? Please go back to GLASS jars.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Steve, We’re sorry to hear you are disappointed with the packaging for Blue Plate Mayonnaise. We will certainly pass your concerns on to our Operations Department. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  8. Shawanna

    Used Blue plate real mayonnaise to make potato salad and for the love of god grease rose up through to the surface… I collected in pools on top… it was a waste of time and money cause not only was the mayo a waste my potatoes and eggs and all the ingredients that were used. It had this weird taste of rancid oil but it wasn’t expired… totally disappointed maybe this is just for sandwich use

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Shawanna, We are sorry to her that you had this experience with Blue Plate Mayonnaise. If you are a regular Blue Plate user you know this is not typical of the product. There are many factors that may have caused this issue. We’ve forwarded your information on to our Consumer Relations Department. Someone will be reaching out to gather additional information.

  9. Linda Hardin

    I have eaten Blue plate mayonnaise all my life and there is no other brand. BUT, the most recent 2 jars I bought set me on fire!🔥
    Like I was looking for jalapeño juice sitting around somewhere. Please tell me that this is not the “new normal”. My ulcers will insist I switch to something milder. Very disappointed. I

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Linda, We are so sorry that you had this experience. Your information has been forward to our Consumer Relations Department. Someone will be reaching out to you. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  10. Mi

    Good product.Do you have a big jar 128oz ?

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Mi, Blue Plate Mayonnaise is available in a 128oz jar. You can find it at many Walmart and Sam’s locations. Contact our Consumer Relations department for assistance in locating a store near you 1 – (800) 535-1961, You can also order it through our mail order department. 1-504-272-2939 Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  11. Marie

    Hi, I’ve always been a Blue Plate girl, but something is wrong!!! During the holidays family requested me to make potato salad and I did. When it was all done I scooped me a little for a taste test, and boy oh boy my mouth was on fire and I can handle spicy. I have never ever had a jar of BP like that. Well, at first thought I figured maybe it was interacting with a medication. But, no it wasn’t everyone at the dinner had same problem MOUTH ON FIRE AND HOT!!!! Threw the whole of potato salad out! I have since bought a second jar and got made my neighbor a sandwich and it’s HOT!!!
    I wish someone from your end could try it, because there is definitely something not right! Giving it 3 stars because i love my BP, but it ain’t what I’m use to.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Marie, We have forwarded your information on to our Consumer Relations department. Someone will be reaching out. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  12. Lee Snarr

    SOYBEAN OIL is the problem. Shouldn’t be consumed in anything including MAYO.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Thank you Lee, We appreciate feedback from all consumers. We hear and understand your concerns for the use of soybean oil in our product, and will be sure to pass this along to our product development department for their review. Blue Plate Mayonnaise, Made Like Homemade!

  13. Linda

    Sorry, I cannot recommend. I tried and thought it tasted like old stale oil. Blue Plate sent me a coupon which I redeemed and the second jar tasted the same. It is well within expiration date. I’m curious that it may be storage conditions of the gricery store. Regardless, I will not buy again and will stick to Hellmann’s or my own homemade. to Blue Plate for ‘trying’ to make it right.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Linda, We appreciate all feedback from Blue Plate Mayonnaise consumers and are sorry that you were disappointed. Thank you for reaching out, and for giving Blue Plate a second try. We understand that everyone has their own unique taste profiles and that all products are not for all consumers. Made Like Homemade Since 1927!

  14. Jordan

    I hope that anyone who accidentally gave this a 1 star rating changes their review. This stuff has literally changed my life. I developed an egg white allergy several years ago. Also, I moved to Kansas shortly before that. I took my husband back to my Homeland (Louisiana) for our honeymoon and totally remembered how special blue plate was. Thank god i read the ingredients (in high hopes that I could eat it) and I must have skimmed over that at least 3 times in utter disbelief that they only use the yolk. Praise the Lord. I haven’t had potato salad in years or chicken salad. Or crawfish dip. Y’all, things are about to get real in my kitchen. ♥️

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Jordan, Thank you for sharing your story. Yes, Blue Plate only uses the egg yolk in our mayonnaise. It’s what sets us apart from the other mayonnaise out there. We are so happy that you will now be able to enjoy those delicious hometown, southern recipes again!

  15. Bonnie O’C

    Born and raised in Louisiana, I now live in Maryland. I can get by without some things, but not Blue Plate mayonnaise. When I visit N.O.L.A family I always bring enough mayo back to last till next visit. My family says if it isn’t Blue Plate don’t bother.

  16. Brenda D. Stone

    The only mayo made is Blue Plate. If it is not BP it is an imposter. I am looking for individual packets of BP.

  17. Cajungirl

    I live in Minnesota now and my dad ships me this amazing Mayo from Louisiana that I have got a lot of people hooked here in the North. I am getting the 2 new flavors in my box for Christmas that I can’t wait to try. This is the best Mayo ever.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hey Cajungirl! We LOVE hearing from our Blue Plate fans. Come back and let us know how you enjoyed the new Go Bold flavors!

  18. Freddy Fender

    Love it

  19. Powers PenelopeСѓ

    For lovers of Mayonnaise (rather than salad dressing), this one is great but it s hard to tell whether Blue Plate or Hellmans are the best. They are super close.

  20. O’Neal’ Allyson

    My family is from the South, we are known Thor cooking and eat we used to play in everything from sandwiches crab shrimp dip po boys if it s not blue plate my family ain t eating.

  21. Lynne Mango

    My Son In Law introduce Blue plate when he brought some back from his home in Louisiana. We were Helmans people now Blue Plate is the only mayo in our house!

  22. Diane Camel

    Having purchased several food items from Walmart to be shipped to me, I was a few dollars short of free shipping so I looked around their site to see if there was anything else I needed. Being a mayonnaise connoiseur (there are very few foods in this world that aren’t better with mayonnaise), I looked at what they offered. I saw Blue Plate, but being 100% yankee, I’d never heard of the brand. The reviews sounded good so I figured, what the heck, and ordered a two-pack. This stuff is GOOD! It is the best mayo of all the brands I have tried. I’m a convert.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *