Blue Plate Sandwich Spread 16oz

Blue Plate Sandwich Spread 16 oz

(83 customer reviews)

$4.50

Or buy 12 for $3.99 per item.

Dress up a lucky po-boy with this sandwich spread, and add zesty flavor with a hint of sweetness to subs, clubs, and burgers alike.

63 in stock

Find Blue Plate Sandwich Spread 16 oz in a Store

83 reviews for Blue Plate Sandwich Spread 16 oz

  1. Rachael

    How can I order if it’s out of stock on your website? It isn’t in any of the stores that you’ve listed.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Rachael, We’re sorry that you are having difficulty finding Blue Plate Sandwich Spread. Have you tried our Find A Store feature to locate a retailer near you? Your information was forwarded to our Consumer Affairs Department. Someone will be reaching out to help. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer!

  2. ifaye4125 (verified owner)

    Blue Plate Sandwich Spread isn’t sold in stores in Little Rock, AR since Reily started making it again. Before Blue Plate Sandwich Spread was taken off the market, it was sold at Walmart, Edwards’s Food Giant, Value Foods, and Kroger’s. I’ve ordered direct from Reilly’s; the cost of shipping is expensive. Did Reily inform previous sellers Blue Plate Sandwich Spread was returning?

  3. Jonathan Felton (verified owner)

    Glad I found this and keeping it a secret! 40 years of blue plate sandwich spread and it disappeared. I ordered 4 bottles to see if it was the same and omg it’s better in my opinion. Just secured a large order for my family! We are greatly appreciative it’s back in production! Keep up the good work!

  4. ty

    are you bringing this back with the original recipe. please do right by the blue plate brand. it doesn’t make sense to buy a company and then change everything people love about the company. i haven’t been able to make several dishes because of the interruption in production. just give us the original recipe so we can make it ourselves at this point.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Ty, Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate Sandwich Spread consumer! Reily Foods Company acquired Blue Plate Mayonnaise in 1974 and have since maintained the original recipe for the Sandwich Spread products. After a timely delay due to sourcing constraints we are happy to say that the product is now back in full production and you should see it on shelf soon. Check our store locator to see if it is in stock at a retailer near you. https://reilyproducts.com/find-a-store/ If not, you can always order to here at https://reilyproducts.com/products/blue-plate-sandwich-spread-16-oz/.

  5. Rita Brown

    I ordered 6 blue plate sandwich spread today I’m so glad that Reilly Food Company did not stop making this wonderful product Thanks Reilly Company so very much No 1

  6. Elena Roby

    Taste like mayonnaise, would love the original recipe back please and thank you

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Elena, We sorry to hear that you are disappointed with Blue Plate Sandwich Spread. You’re information was forwarded to our Consumer Affairs Department. Someone will be reaching out to help.

  7. Johnnie Davenport

    When will we be able to purchase the Blue Plate Sandwich Spread in stores again? Desperately waiting, it’s been a long time since I have been able to make tuna salad or potato salad.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Johnnie, The product is back in full production and is shipping to most of the same retailers that carried it in the past. Please keep checking in stores near you. It will be on shelf soon! Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate Sandwich Spread user!

  8. Linda

    I am 73 and have been eating the mayo and sandwich spread all my life. We eat the sandwich spread just on bread plain as a sandwich and now my granddaughters ages 4 and 6 eat it and they keep begging for it. And I can’t find it anywhere. Why are you all not making any more? Please please don’t stop making it

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Linda, Blue Plate Sandwich Spread is back in full production and is shipping to most of the same retailers that carried it in the past. Please keep checking in the stores near you. It will be on shelf soon. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate Sandwich Spread user!

  9. Carrita Cloud

    Just ordered 12 of the large size. My mom and I have been waiting for this. We use it for our deviled eggs, potato salad, tuna fish and sandwich spread. Thank you so much for not discontinuing and for releasing the larger size! I can’t wait for delivery!

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Carrita, Thank you for being a loyal Blue Plate Sandwich Spread consumer! And for the awesome purchase. We’re all excited that the product is back in full production again. The Deviled Eggs this Memorial Day will be…DELICIOUS!!!

  10. Trevor

    I got an email from an online grocery store that it was in stock and was able to order six jars today 5/17. I am not sure if I can share the vendor here. But if anyone wants to know send me an email and I will share it with you myretailemail520@gmail.com

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Trevor, We are happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread is now in production and will be available online and in retailer within the next week! Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate Sandwich Spread lover!

  11. Darcel

    When can we expect blue plate sandwich spread to be back on shelves? This all I’ve known since a lil girl. This is the only thing my paternal grandmother used and the rest of my family. This is the only thing I use for sandwiches, tuna, devil eggs and potato salad. Please bring this back soon

  12. Wanda F

    I cater and blue plate sandwich spread is one of my go to ingredients for several dishes that I cook, and it’s just the best all around. Please bring it back, it was all my grandparents and parents ever used. We never ate any other kind of sandwich spread because that is the best.

  13. Elaine K

    What’s going on? Blue Plate Sandwich Spread was used in our family for over 60 years. We are hoping to see the product back into production very soon. We miss our Blue Plate Sandwich Spread.

  14. Janis McFarland

    For months probably a year or so now, we have had to do without our Blue Plate Sandwich Spread. My husband will not even try eating devil eggs, potato salad, or chicken salad without Blue Plate Sandwich Spread. This is the only sandwich spread that my grandmother, mother, mother-in-law and now me will ever use. We have heard for months that it is an ingredient sourcing issue. What is the ingredient that you are having trouble getting? Please get it back on the market. I am in desperate need of some Blue Plate Sandwich Spread.

  15. Mo’Nique

    I have missed Thanksgiving, Christmas, the New Year and now Easter without having deviled eggs and potato salad due to not having any Blue Plate Sandwich Spread. Please bring this back ASAP. The spring is here and summer is near. My family is ready to BBQ and Blue Plate Sandwich Spread is a huge part of our meals. Other brand have been a waste of my money and they taste like trash.

  16. Michelle

    We threw away a dozen deviled eggs made with Kraft sandwich spread at Thanksgiving. It was that bad. Please, please, please hurry back. We can’t eat deviled eggs again until your spread is back!!!!

  17. Angie

    When will y’all have this back in stock? I can’t make chicken salad sandwiches or deviled eggs without blue plate sandwich spread!!!! The other ones taste like cat crap! Please bring this back to in stock status!!!! Like what the what is going on with blue plate? It is most certainly not a supply chain issue! Let your customers know what is going on here!!!

  18. Angela Dunn

    Blue Plate Sandwich Spread is great. Reily Foods, not so much. Can’t make me believe this is a sourcing problem. No worries…. I’ve concocted my own version that makes it doubtful I’ll ever buy another jar of your sandwich spread.

  19. Wanda Scott

    I WANT BLUE PLATE SANDWICH SPREAD BACK. IT’S THE BEST NONE CAN COMPARE!! IT’S THE BEST BAND THE REST!!!!!!!!!!!

  20. Carmen T.

    This shortage has been going on for 7 months. It has to be more going on than a sourcing or supply chain issue. I am starting to believe it’s never coming back and you just don’t want to say it.

  21. Terry Richard

    When is Blue Plate Sandwich Spread coming back?! That damn Kraft Sandwich Spread ruined my infamous potato salad. There is nothing like this product on the market. We’re suffering without it… so our dishes!

  22. Ruby Burrell

    This is the best sandwich spread there is no other one to replace it it has been to long out of service

  23. Ingrien Charpentier

    Please, please, please bring Blue Plate Sandwich Spread back! Nothing compares to it. I make a shrimp dip recipe that call for it and is just not the same with the other brand.

  24. Jeanne B.

    Blue Plate Mayo was the only mayo allowed in my growing up home and in my now home. I’m almost 70 years old.
    And, I never order a sandwich with mayo when I’m out because you never know what mayo is on it. If it ain’t BP then, forget about it. I ain’t eating it.

    Started using BP sandwich spread in my deviled eggs when I was in my 20’s. Once people had my eggs, they would want me to always fix them. Had a man once tell me he was in love. With the eggs. Seriously.

    Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year’s Eve was not the same without my eggs. Though, I tried to make some decent deviled eggs. My daughter said they were horrible.

    I don’t know about mass production and why yall can’t get some spread produced. I know myself and family, and thousands more sure do miss our BP sandwich spread.

    I hope yall will email all of us when we can start seeing BPSS back in the stores.

    Thank you for taking the time to read my email,

    Jeanne B.

  25. Michelle Richardson

    I just got the news today after searching multiple stores for my FAVORITE sandwich spread. It’s been a part of my family for decades. I hope that it doesn’t take too long for it to be back in production. My sandwiches, tuna, chicken, or potato salad, are not the same without it.

  26. James jones

    Please bring back Blue Plate Sandwich Spread I can’t make my potato salad without it that other spread sucks you know which one so hurry and bring back Blue Plate

  27. Kat

    Liver cheese sandwiches and my recipes aren’t the same. I don’t understand how there’s a sourcing of ingredients problem since production had already decreased after Katrina. I found a replacement under a generic label, it tastes similar but the texture and color is different. In fact, BPSS texture has itself been different since Katrina compared to what I grew up eating since the 50s. Please don’t give up, the product put out by your major competitor that starts with a K is no substitute, but the generic product is a close second.

    Now I am wondering, do you even have the original recipe since this is Reilly’s and not Blue Plate produced?

    • Reily Foods Company

      We’re trying Kat, we’re trying. Soon, hopefully soon.

  28. Jennie

    Please pretty please bring back the blue plate sandwich spread.

  29. Reather Levy

    Do we need to start a protest because I need my blue plate sandwich spread. Whatever y’all need to do to get it back in stock, Do It!! No potatoes salad for holidays and Sunday dinners is not working for me. Fix it Jesus!
    When my sandwich spread is back the rating will go up

  30. Nana

    When the grandkids asked what we wanted for Christmas? There was only one answer: “Blue Plate Sandwich Spread.” We have been searching the shelves from Louisiana to Texas. Eventhough you say this is only a temporary situation, some products can not be substituted on a sandwich. Get it done BLUE PLATE.

  31. ifaye4125

    Since I have been unable to purchase Blue Plate Sandwich Spread, the best sandwich ever, I started ordering Heinz Sandwich Spread. When making my favorite tuna salad, chicken salad and potato salad recipes with Heinz Sandwich Spread, I add pimentos and cube salad relish. This sort of recreates the Blue Plate Sandwich Spread taste I’ve enjoyed 40 plus years. Please bring back Blue Plate Sandwich Spread.

  32. Jonathan Randolph

    So is the spread in production at all?I’d buy a case or 2 at this point. Hopefully this is resolved soon.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Unfortunately Jonathan, it isn’t in production. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer!

  33. Bett, MS Gulf Coast

    I read some reviews , and the replies from this company is the same , is there someone who is actually getting these complaints …a real person?

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Elliott Bett, Thanks for the inquiry. Yes, we have a real person that responds to consumer reviews. In some cases where the question is fairly repetitive, the response may be as well. So’s the case with Blue Plate Sandwich Spread. For some time now we have had problems sourcing a major ingredient that is used in this beloved product. So when the question comes up again as to when it will be back in stock and we have no new news on when it will be, we use the most recent response from our Operations Team. As of now we are still testing alternatives and hope to have a shippable product soon. Thanks again for the inquiry and for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  34. Bettye

    OH MY GOODNESS!! What in the world is going on with this spread?? It has been around since 1927 and now it’s out of stock? My mom used it when I was a little girl and now I’m a mature adult who also used it. There are other companies who “try” to copy it but the missed the mark by a long shot , and I will NOT buy any other brands. You say it would be back by Thanksgiving, sooo where is it… still can’t find it. I read on another site where it is discontinued, is that true? Can you tell me where I can find it ?
    Thank you!

  35. May Green

    It’s a sad day, what are we supposed to do without potato salad and deviled eggs Do y’all understand what’s going on in the world? What is it you need to fix it? Come on y’all get it back in the stores.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi May, We know, and we understand. Thanksgiving was just not the same without Blue Plate Sandwich Spread :(.

      For some time now we have had problems sourcing a major ingredient that is used in this beloved product. As of now we are still testing alternatives and hope to have a shippable product soon. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  36. Rudolph Garcia

    Please get the sandwich spread back soon because it is an important ingredient for my Great-Grandmother’s recipe potato salad! I have to make it or it’s not Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner without it!

  37. Dee

    OK now Blue Plate…. they are offering the other brand that I’ll never indulge in. Where is the sandwich spread 🤔

  38. KaTina Williams

    Everyone raves about my potato salad, I use your sandwich spread. We need this back in stock, please do what you can. Blue Plate is our only option, most of us just won’t make our dishes without it.
    K Williams, Mississippi

  39. Angela

    When is coming back!!!! Best on the market:-( ruined thanksgiving no potatoe salad or deviled eggs we ONLY used Blue Plate sandwiche spread in our recipe

  40. Jacqueline Hughes

    I have been looking every where for blue plate sandwich spread, I can’t find it anywhere at all. I’m in a wheel chair just imagine going from store to store looking. I also, have others in different state, and city ,and they still can’t find it.

  41. kellee

    when will it be back in stock, we need it before thanksgiving

  42. Sondra Smith

    I & my family love Blue Plate Sandwich Spread, especially my 102 yr old mother. Eating a sandwich, potato salad or tuna isn’t the same without it. Please make more, holidays are just around the corner.
    Signed,
    Sad 😥Sondra in Alexandria

  43. Lynn

    I can’t handle this news. How are we suppose to have great potato salad, tuna, and Chicken salad. The holidays are approaching. Please do something fast. Take the mayo but not the sandwich spread.

  44. melissa

    this is the best sandwich spread I use this to make my potato salad please . get it back soon

  45. Arnetta Hobbs

    Need it bad for Thanksgiving and Christmas blue plate sandwich spread

  46. Doris Benford

    Blue Plate is the best sandwich there is. Please, please say you will have it back in stock for Thanksgiving. I am 69 years old and Blue plate has been used in my family for all our sandwiches and salads.

  47. Kathesia

    I am so needing Blue Plate Sandwich spread like weeks ago. I miss this dearly. I use this to make my tuna sandwiches (So So Good), my potato salad as well my devine eggs (Simply Heavenly). Please bring it back 911!! An ultimate must have!!!

  48. Bobby Nees

    I hope it becomes in stock soon . Thanksgiving won’t be the same. I use it to make my potato salad.

    • Reily Foods Company

      We know Bobby, we know. We’re trying our best to get it back into production. Sorry for the disappointment. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate lover!

  49. Ruby Kelly

    I started using Blue Plate sandwich spread for sometime now and it makes your food taste extra special, I use it as a secret ingredient in some of my items I cook. Very disappointed I can’t find any no where, not even on line.

  50. Jeraldine Dailey

    Please hurry with the sandwich spread. It is hard for me to make a sandwich at home because I am out of my sandwich spread. I lived 15 years in a city that had never heard of this sandwich spread. But whenever I got to come home, I always stocked up to travel with it. That was my tuna’s secret ingredient and they loved it at every gathering we had. Can hardly wait until you get back on our shelves.

  51. Jackie Lancaster

    I was wondering why I couldn’t find any on the shelves lately. I’m probably going to have to buy a case because when it returns. This is the 2nd time that this has happened. I won’t buy any other brand. This is what I grew up on. I wish you could bring back the 32oz size. I don’t know why that one was discontinued. You make the Mayonnaise in the 32oz. still, can you bring back the 32oz.

  52. Dennis Gooch

    Any idea when Blue Plate sandwich spread will be available again?
    Other brands are not a decent substitute. They don’t even come close to BP

  53. TADK (verified owner)

    I have been eating Blue Plate Sandwich Spread for over 60 years, since growing up in the South. I remember when it was in glass jars and had a metal lid. I usually try to keep it on hand, but I ran out a couple of months ago, and can’t wait to order more. Unfortunately, I’ve had to purchase another brand, to try and keep me going until it’s back in stock. I check the inventory status at least 5 times a day, with hopes that I can get my hands on some. Please make this available soon. My plan is to order enough to last a minimum of 8-12 months, just in case I run into this issue again of “Out of Stock”. Looking forward to available inventory soon, I hope. Whatever you do, please do not discontinue this product.

  54. Rachael Henry

    I live in Florida now, I was in River Ridge back In July and I found 4-8 oz jars of sandwich spread at Breaux Mart, I am savoring every spoonful. I use it for my Tuna and chicken salad. Please make more soon! I will not use anything else. They sell my mayo here but not the sandwich spread.

    • Reily Foods Company

      WOW!! That’s exciting news. We can’t believe someone else had not scooped them up by now! Our Operations team is working hard to get the product back on the shelf for us. Hopefully it will be soon. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer!

  55. Ann

    Can we please get an update on the blue plate sandwich

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Ann, We LOVE hearing from our loyal Blue Plate consumers!! Don’t worry…We’re happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread has not been discontinued. But like with a many other manufacturers, sourcing certain ingredients has been a challenge. We are hoping to have the product back into production very soon. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer!

  56. RITA Brown

    This is the best sandwich spread please stock the shelves soon

  57. Dennis Gooch

    Love blue plate sandwich spread. I will be so glad when it is available again. A bologna sandwich with Blue Plate Sandwich Spread, as good as a steak to me.

  58. Corey Carver

    I love blue plate mayonnaise and sandwich spread its the only kind I will use nothing else can compare to the yummy taste of blue plate. My mom thought kraft sandwich spread would be the same I took that nasty stuff and threw it in the trash can and told her blue plate sandwich spread is the only sandwich spread I will use. I literally put it on every sandwich,burger or poboys. Can’t wait until it’s back in stock at my local Walmart

  59. Timitra Jones

    I ran out of this sandwich spread about 2 months ago & I can’t find any anywhere. Kraft sandwich spread is no substitute, it’s completely & absolutely GARBAGE! I NEED BLUE PLATE. Please let me know if I can order directly from the company or will I be back in stores soon. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE!!

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Timitra, We LOVE hearing from our loyal Blue Plate consumers!! Don’t worry…We’re happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread has not been discontinued. But like with a many other manufacturers, sourcing certain ingredients has been a challenge. We are hoping to have the product back into production very soon.

  60. Regina Fleming

    Blue Plate Sandwich Spread are not in the stores again. Do you have a shipping date to the stores in Mississippi?

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Regina, We LOVE hearing from our loyal Blue Plate consumers!! Don’t worry…We’re happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread has not been discontinued. But like with a many other manufacturers, sourcing certain ingredients has been a challenge. We are hoping to have the product back into production very soon.

  61. Harvey n Smith

    When will blue plate sandwich spread be back on shelves in southaven Mississippi

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Harvey, We LOVE hearing from our loyal Blue Plate consumers!! Don’t worry…We’re happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread has not been discontinued. But like with a many other manufacturers, sourcing certain ingredients has been a challenge. We are hoping to have the product back into production very soon.

  62. Von

    Still can’t find the sandwich spread. I’ve looked in two different states and no luck. When can I expect to see it?

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Von, We LOVE hearing from our loyal Blue Plate consumers!! Don’t worry…We’re happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread has not been discontinued. But like with a many other manufacturers, sourcing certain ingredients has been a challenge. We are hoping to have the product back into production very soon.

  63. James Berry

    I have searched everywhere for sandwich spread and no luck. Pretty please with sugar on top HELP

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi James, We LOVE hearing from our loyal Blue Plate consumers!! Don’t worry…We’re happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread has not been discontinued. But like with a many other manufacturers, sourcing certain ingredients has been a challenge. We are hoping to have the product back into production very soon.

  64. Toni Beamon

    No review – just a request. Email when resuming shipments of sandwich spread. Please and thank you.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Toni, Please follow up with our Customer Relations Department for the shipping information. 1-800-535-1961 Thanks!

  65. Harvey Perkins

    I need my fix of Blue Plate sandwich spread. Please hurry!

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Harvey, Our sentiments exactly! We will forward your request on to our operations department. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  66. brenda

    When will it be back in stores

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Brenda, Product started shipping last week. You should see it in stores soon. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  67. Laura Jane

    When will blue plate sandwich spread be available? We use it in everything. Thank you

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Laura, Product started shipping last week. You should see it in stores soon. Thanks for being a loyal Blue Plate consumer.

  68. vessie blair

    I work at Walmart and we have had tons of customer asking for blue sandwich spread please ship some to Walmart on Louisville Avenue in monroe louisiana ASAP

    • Reily Foods Company

      HI Vessie, Product started shipping last week. If orders were in, you should start seeing it instore soon! Thanks for checking in for your loyal Blue Plate customers!

  69. Linda

    Found it. We too like many of you use the sandwich spread for recipes. My husband prayed and asked God to show him. God said “go to small stores”. He found it at neighborhood stores and a local gas station. This is good stuff. Blessings on your journey

  70. Katrina Braden

    Like many others, this is my main ingredient for my tuna salad sandwiches, chicken salad, potato salad, and most importantly… my deviled eggs!!! Why can’t I find it on the shelves or online. Please put it back and please don’t change the contents or consistency

  71. Randy Cook

    WHEN WILL IT BE BACK FOR SALE ON LINE. NEED TO PUT IT IN QUART JARS LIKE THE MAYONNAISE

    • Reily Foods Company

      We don’t have an exact date, but it will be soon! Please keep checking with our Customer Service department 1 – (800) 535-1961 😊

  72. Valencia V Wagner

    I’ve been looking for this awesome sandwich spread, this is my main ingredient for my deviled Eggs I’ve been making for over 30 years, please don’t discontinue this product

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Valencia, We know what you mean! Deviled Eggs without Blue Plate Sandwich Spread would not be the same. Soon Valencia, soon.

  73. Barbara Ross

    I am so ready to see sandwich spread back on the shelves.. I can’t make potato salad without it..

  74. Rita Brown

    What time will blue plate sandwich spread be on shelves before Thankgiving

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Rita, We don’t have an exact date, but it will be soon.

  75. Edna Quinney

    What’s happening with my Blue Plate sandwich spread. I have searched everywhere. Did you all stop making it. I need it for sandwiches, potatoes salads, chicken salad…everything

    • Reily Foods Company

      We have great news. Blue Plate Sandwich Spread will be back into production in early November and is expected to be on store shelves before the Thanksgiving Holiday!

  76. Pam

    Please get Blue Plate Sandwich Spread back on the shelves soon! Potato salad just doesn’t taste as good without it!! Thank you…

    • Reily Foods Company

      Soon Pam….Soon!

  77. SHARON TINSON

    PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE I need some Blue Plate Sandwich Spread. My family only use Blue plate mayo and sandwich spread.

    • Reily Foods Company

      We have great news. Blue Plate Sandwich Spread will be back into production in early November and is expected to be on store shelves before the Thanksgiving Holiday!

  78. Darlene

    I looked everywhere for that best ever sandwich spread but to no avail. I hit every store but nothing on shelf. Only Mayo. Please produce them as soon as fast and store on shelves ASAP. Please send me coupons if you have.

  79. Kevin Thomas

    When will u have sandwich spread back on shelves

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Kevin, We have great news. Blue Plate Sandwich Spread will be back into production in early November and is expected to be on store shelves before the Thanksgiving Holiday!

  80. Jacquelyn Lancaster

    I cannot find blue plate sandwich spread anywhere. This is the only thing I use in my potato salad, tuna salads. It’s so frustrating when you see the mayo and not the sandwich spread.

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Jacquelyn, We have great news. Blue Plate Sandwich Spread will be back into production in early November and is expected to be on store shelves before the Thanksgiving Holiday!

  81. Mitzi Tucker

    Where’s the Blue Plate Sandwich Spread??? My family and I grew up with this sandwich spread. I make my potato salad, deviled eggs, tuna salad and chicken salad with it and I WILL NOT use any other brand. I’m praying that this product will be back on the shelves really soon as the Holidays are fast approaching!

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Mitzi, We LOVE hearing from our loyal Blue Plate consumers!! We’re happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread has not been discontinued. But like with a many other manufactures sourcing certain ingredients has been a challenge this past year. We are hoping to have the product back into production very soon. Please keep checking back with us.

  82. Jan Giordano

    I’ve been to 4 stores in the last 2 days looking for it! I use it in my chicken salad and my potato salad.

    I wanted to make potato salad yesterday to go along with my chicken and sausage gumbo. I use a mixture of mayo and sandwich spread. I will not use any other brand! I will keep looking! Thanks for the information.

  83. Shirley A Holden

    This is the best sandwich spread i ever tasted! Very disappointed that i cant find it in stores anymore. I grew up with this
    sandwich spread. This is the only sandwich spread i use to make potato salad. i cant even imagine what my Thanksgiving dinner will be like without it!
    Please, Please get it back on the shelves

    • Reily Foods Company

      Hi Shirley, We LOVE hearing from our loyal Blue Plate consumers!! We’re happy to say that Blue Plate Sandwich Spread has not been discontinued. But like with a many other manufactures sourcing certain ingredients has been a challenge this past year. We are hoping to have the product back into production soon. Please keep checking back with us.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *